Aragon client smart contracts bug bounty

A bug bounty for the smart contracts in the Aragon client is now live. We intend for hackers to look for smart contract vulnerabilities in our system that can lead to loss of funds or locked DAOs.

Rewards

Vulnerability reports will be scored using the CVSS v3 standard. The reward amounts for different types of vulnerabilities are:

Critical (CVSS 9.0 - 10.0)

$5,000 - $50,000

Major (CVSS 7.0 - 8.9)

$2,500 - $5,000

Medium (CVSS 4.0 - 6.9)

$1,000 - $2,500

Low (CVSS 1.0 - 3.9)

$500 - $1,000

Rewards will be awarded at the sole discretion of the Aragon Association. Quality of the report and reproduction instructions can impact the reward. Rewards are denominated in USD and will be paid out in ETH.

For this initial bug bounty program, there is a maximum bounty pool of $250,000.

The bug bounty program is ongoing and has ran since October 17th, 2018.

Reporting

Reporting a found vulnerability

Please responsibly disclose any findings to the development team. You may find instructions on how to do so in the security overview page.

Failure to do so will result in a finding being ineligible for any bounties.

Scope

In scope for the bug bounty are all the smart contract components of the Aragon client. They can be found in the following repositories:

aragonOS 4 ([email protected] and future patch versions)

Smart contract framework and the core of the system.

  • Solidity code under the contracts directory:
    • Excluding contracts/lib/ens/
    • Excluding contracts/test/

aragon-apps (on the master branch)

Contracts for Aragon apps developed by the Aragon Association and are installed by default in most Aragon organizations.

  • Solidity code under apps/**/contracts (agent, finance, payroll, survey, token-manager, vault, voting)
    • Excluding contracts/example/
    • Excluding contracts/test/

dao-templates (on the master branch, Aragon 0.8 tag, Aragon 0.7 tag, and Aragon 0.6 tag)

On-chain deployment templates for Aragon DAOs.

  • Solidity code in the templates/**/contracts and shared/contracts/
    • Excluding templates/**/contracts/test and shared/contracts/test

dandelion in each of their app and template repos

Dandelion organization template (dandelion-org on the v1.0.0 tag)

  • Solidity code under the contracts directory:
  • Excluding contracts/examples/, contracts/misc/, and contracts/test/

Dandelion voting app (dandelion-voting-app on the v2.0.0 tag)

  • Solidity code under the contracts directory:
  • Excluding contracts/examples/, contracts/misc/, and contracts/test/

Delay app (delay-app on the v1.1.0 tag)

  • Solidity code under the contracts directory:
  • Excluding contracts/examples/, contracts/misc/, and contracts/test/

Redemptions app (redemptions-app on the v2.0.0 tag)

  • Solidity code under the contracts directory:
  • Excluding contracts/examples/, contracts/misc/, and contracts/test/

Time Lock app (time-lock-app on the v2.0.0 tag)

  • Solidity code under the contracts directory:
  • Excluding contracts/examples/, contracts/misc/, and contracts/test/

Token Oracle app (token-oracle on the v1.1.0 tag)

  • Solidity code under the contracts directory:
  • Excluding contracts/examples/, contracts/misc/, and contracts/test/

Token Request app (token-request-app on the v2.0.0 tag)

  • Solidity code under the contracts directory:
  • Excluding contracts/examples/, contracts/misc/, and contracts/test/

fundraising (on the v1.0.0 tag)

Contracts for Aragon Fundraising developed by Aragon Black.

  • Solidity code under apps/**/contracts (aragon-fundraising, batched-bancor-market-maker, presale, tap)
    • Excluding apps/bancor-formula
    • Excluding contracts/test/
  • Solidity code under templates/multisig
    • Excluding contracts/test/

MiniMe Token (Aragon fork) (on the master branch)

Governance token deployed for most Aragon organizations.

  • Solidity code under the contracts directory:
    • Excluding contracts/test/

You can find their deployed addresses on live networks in our deployment documentation.

Out of scope

What we consider out of scope for this bug bounty

  • Side-effects of properly authenticated smart contract upgrades or contract upgrades that change the storage layout of a contract.
  • Revocation of permissions or completely changing how a DAO operates due to important permission being granted through the proper processes.
  • Any frontend applications or client-side code interacting with the contracts, as well as testing code.
  • Mismatch of the functionality of the contracts and outdated spec documents.

Areas of interest

These are some examples of vulnerabilities that would be interesting

  • Bypassing ACL rules to get unauthorized access to an app.
  • A user of an app performing an action that could freeze or lock the contract.
  • Being able to escalate permissions using the Voting app or Token Manager without a proper vote being successful.

Resources

Documentation and resources for hackers

Eligibility

Terms for eligible bounties

  • Only unknown vulnerabilities will be awarded a bounty; in case of duplicate reports, the first report will be awarded the bounty.
  • Public disclosure of the vulnerability, before explicit consent from Aragon to do so, will make the vulnerability ineligible for a bounty.
  • Attempting to exploit the vulnerability in a public Ethereum network will also make it ineligible for a bounty.